Crescent Warbler

 

Click image to enlarge

For more information about native warblers, see this post.


Crescent Warbler, Geothlypis crescens L 10-15 cm, WS 18-20 cm, Family: Parulidae


IUCN Conservation Status: Least concern (LC)

 

Description:    

Small, active songbird with round body, large head, and long tail. Full-bodied and chunky for a warbler. Yellow-green overall, with olive upperparts and yellow undersides, with gray head. Males have a black throat and lores and a distinct, white, crescent-shaped band across breast. Females paler overall with a less distinct breast patch and lacking the black throat. Both sexes have obvious white eye-ring. Pinkish legs long, more obvious than in other native warblers; bill pinkish, heavy.

Voice:

Song is a slow, burry warble, usually descending in pitch. Song usually three to five syllables, lasting one to two seconds, often written as Cheery-churry-chore. Song is slower and deeper than other native warblers. The most common call is a short, metallic tsik.    

Range and Habitat:    

Summer range encompasses most of Novasola, excluding the interior steppe, but more common in higher elevations and wetter climates. Migrates to spend winter in southern California and Mexico. Can be found in most wooded ecosystem types like conifer, deciduous, and mixed forests, shrublands, and wetlands, but are usually found only in areas with dense understory vegetation or shrub layer. Associated with secondary growth or disturbed areas within forests and riparian thickets.    

Discussion:      

Not to be confused with the Crescent-chested Warbler of Mexico, the Crescent Warbler is likewise named for their obvious breast band, but Crescent Warblers can still pose a challenge for identification, as their small size and habitat preferences make them difficult to observe. However, Crescents are notably slow-moving and heavy for a warbler, as is their song, which is often the best feature to use to distinguish them.

Crescent Warblers forage deep within dense cover and eat mostly insects and other invertebrates which they pick from foliage or the ground. Their preferred food sources include caterpillars, ants, moths, beetles, flies, and bees. They have been observed on rare occasions eating berries. Often they skulk within thickets of willow, alder, rhododendron, manzanita, ceanothus, and raspberry, but will at times forage higher, into the subcanopy, especially in dogwood and young Coopers-fir and spruce.    

Like most native warblers, Crescents winter off the island in California, Arizona, and Mexico, but they breed on Novasola, arriving in mid-to-late May and leaving in mid-August. When males arrive in the spring, they establish territories, which they do mostly through song. Crescent Warblers may sing from exposed perches or from under dense cover, but it is much more common to hear them than to see them, as even when exposed their coloration, though bright, easily camouflages them. Multiple neighboring males will sing over one another, making shrub thickets seem to echo with song. Crescent Warblers form monogamous pairs during breeding. Females build nests, usually near the ground in areas of dense, in not seemingly impenetrable, vegetation, often in the crook of forking stems, and both parents will incubate eggs and feed chicks. They are very secretive when near the nest, and this makes finding Crescent Warbler nests extremely difficult.

Closely related to the MacGillivray’s Warbler and Mourning Warbler from mainland North America, the three species form an interesting phenomenon, similar to a “ring species” phenomenon, where connected populations may form hybrids with each other while the two end species are too distantly related to hybridize. In this case, Crescent Warblers can hybridize with MacGillivray’s Warblers, and MacGillivray’s can hybridize with Mourning Warblers, but Mourning and Crescent Warblers cannot form hybrids, even though some Crescent Warblers breed outside Novasola in Canada where their ranges overlap with both other species. This has become a recent topic of much research and debate over what constitutes a “species”.   


Like most endemic warblers on Novasola, few writings or references to the Crescent Warbler exist before Reichwald’s descriptions for the Novasola Research Corps. Since then the Crescent has remained somewhat mysterious, despite its abundance; an infrequently studied common warbler. In recent years however there has been a marked uptick in Crescent Warbler research, especially genetic studies. Their habitat preferences and stealthy nesting habits are likely to blame for the gaps in knowledge.  


“An upside to this area is the abundance of birdlife. Perhaps of most interest to me are the many warblers I have observed and heard during this hike, of at least three varieties, all of which yellow. Having not yet gotten a good look at any, I have relied so far only on song to differentiate them. I don’t know whether this area is particularly dense with warblers when compared to other stretches of the Fastwaters, as it seems, but I am hopeful I should get the chance to study them in great detail.” – Expedition log, May 29, 1902   


“Similar in habit and in habitat, the Crescent Warbler may to the amateur eye be easily confused with that of the Black-eared Warbler. The male plumage of each species is sufficiently distinct alone, but this may be difficult to observe while under cover. Should the bird’s calls not give the identity away, look to form. Where the Back-eared Warbler is small, quick, and bouncy, the Crescent Warbler is corpulent, slow, and methodical.” – Manual to Novasolan Birds, 1914       


“It is the that [Crescent Warbler’s] song which shall always give me reason for pause. Not for some love of the warbled tune or for a particular interest in the bird itself, but for what I know that song to be exhibitive of: difficult country. It took only a short time for me, and the rest of the Corps likewise, to understand that should we hear a chorus of Crescent Warblers we could reasonably and reliably expect to be met with dense foliage and shrubbery to impede our forward progress. Indeed, the more warblers we heard the thicker we would expect the country to be with briars and thickets and green, such that instead of continuing to push our way painfully through overgrown and unforgiving lands, we would guide ourselves and determine our path of travel by the absence of such song.” – Native Birds of Novasola, 1912